Law

Employment ban in a nursery: when it applies

Employment ban in a nursery: when it applies

An employment ban in a nursery is the last step of maternity protection, not the first reaction: under section 13 MuSchG the provider must first adapt the working conditions and then check another workplace. Release from work is only allowed if both fail, typically because of missing immunity to rubella.

The basics of the assessment under section 10 MuSchG are in the post Maternity protection in the office. This post covers what differs in a nursery. The placement in the risk assessment works as in the office, but the hazards differ considerably (see also Risk assessment in a nursery).

Why nurseries are a special case for maternity protection

A nursery is a special case because close contact with small children creates an infection risk that does not exist in an office. Lifting and carrying, noise and supervision outdoors come on top. The duties of the Maternity Protection Act apply from the first employee, whatever the size of the provider.

For nurseries run by independent providers the accident insurer is usually the BGW, for municipal nurseries the Unfallkasse. That is not the body to notify about a pregnancy, though: the competent authority is the supervisory authority of the federal state under section 27 MuSchG. The version of the rules issued by your own accident insurer is authoritative.

The employment ban is not a separate procedure but the result of the assessment. A provider that has completed the event-independent assessment under section 10 MuSchG knows before the first report which activities are possible without changes and which are not. Without it, the provider decides under time pressure, and that is when staff are released too quickly.

The order of measures under section 13 MuSchG: adapt first, reassign second

Section 13 (1) MuSchG prescribes three steps in a fixed order: adapting the working conditions, changing the workplace, employer-imposed employment ban. The order is binding. A provider that releases an employee at once without checking steps 1 and 2 breaches it.

Order of protective measures in a nursery under section 13 MuSchG
StepMeasureNursery exampleLimit
1Adapting the working conditionsChanging table with steps, no lifting, no late shift, rest roomInfection risk can hardly be excluded by adapting the work
2Change of workplaceWork in kitchen, administration, parent liaison or management without child contactOnly possible if a suitable position exists and is reasonable
3Employer-imposed employment banFull release from work with continued maternity protection payOnly if steps 1 and 2 are ruled out

In a nursery step 1 often fails on the core of the job: anyone who looks after children has contact, and the contact is the hazard. Step 2 therefore usually decides. Whether it works depends on the size of the facility. A provider with several sites and an administration has more options than a nursery with two groups.

Immunity status: rubella, chickenpox and the limits of disclosure

In practice immunity status decides: section 11 (2) MuSchG expressly names the rubella virus as a hazard for which a pregnant woman without sufficient immunity must not be employed. Without proof the provider has to assume the less favourable case.

The woman does not have to disclose her immunity status or be vaccinated. The provider may ask for proof, for example a vaccination record or a titre. The talk should be confidential, the result belongs in the records, and health data stays limited to the people who need it. If proof exists and protection is sufficient, the educator can continue to work in the group. If it does not, work with child contact is generally not permitted and steps 1 and 2 are checked next.

Besides rubella, other infections belong in the assessment, such as chickenpox, parvovirus B19 and cytomegalovirus. For some there is no vaccine, so the risk can only be reduced through hygiene and organisation. How far the protective measures go is assessed by the occupational safety specialist together with the company doctor. Mandatory screening and instruction under the Infection Protection Act do not replace this assessment.

Employer-imposed vs. medical employment ban

Employer-imposed vs. medical employment ban: the employer imposes the first under section 13 MuSchG, the second rests on a doctor's certificate under section 16 MuSchG. Both lead to release from work, but with a different trigger and a different duty to check.

Employer-imposed vs. medical employment ban
FeatureEmployer-imposed banMedical ban
Legal basisSection 13 (1) no. 3 MuSchGSection 16 MuSchG
TriggerAssessment by the employerDoctor's certificate
ConditionAdapting and reassigning not possibleHealth of woman or child at risk if work continues
Provider's duty to checkCheck and document steps 1 and 2Certificate is the basis, no order-of-measures check
Maternity protection payYes, reimbursable through U2Yes, reimbursable through U2

The difference matters in practice. With a medical ban the doctor carries the decision, with an employer-imposed ban the provider carries it and must be able to prove it.

Three nurseries compared: which step applies

Which step applies in practice depends on immunity status and deployment options. The cases below are assumed examples, not legal advice for an individual case.

Three assumed cases with a likely decision
CaseImmunity statusAlternatives in the organisationLikely decision
Nursery with 2 groups, 8 employeesRubella proof availablenot neededContinue work with adapted tasks, no ban
Nursery with 5 groups, 22 employeesno proofKitchen, parent liaisonChange of workplace (step 2)
Nursery with 2 groups, 8 employeesno proofno position without child contactEmployer-imposed employment ban (step 3)

The third case is the rule in small facilities, not the exception. It is permissible if the check of steps 1 and 2 is documented. Which further duties apply to your size is shown by the duties quick check.

What to do when a pregnancy is reported

After the report four steps run, all due without delay. The woman has no duty to report, section 15 MuSchG words it as a "should".

  1. Clarify immunity status. Ask for proof of immunity to rubella and chickenpox and document the result without forcing the proof.
  2. Check the order of measures. Under section 13 MuSchG: first adapt the work, then reassign, and only last an employer-imposed employment ban.
  3. Offer a talk and notify the authority. Offer the talk under section 10 (2) MuSchG and notify the state authority without delay under section 27 MuSchG.
  4. Document the decision and claim reimbursement. Record every step checked with reasons and have the maternity protection pay reimbursed through the U2 scheme.

Every step that was checked and rejected belongs in the records with reasons. A ban without a traceable check is the mistake that stands out in an inspection by the authority. The dismissal protection of section 17 MuSchG also applies: it runs from the start of the pregnancy until four months after the birth, including during a release from work.

Costs: the provider does not pay permanently

During an employment ban the provider continues to pay maternity protection pay and, as a rule, gets it reimbursed in full by the health insurer through the U2 levy under the Expenditure Compensation Act. Levy rate and exact reimbursement are in the insurer's statutes.

That takes budget pressure out of the decision: a provider does not have to weigh protection against cost. What remains is cover, because in a small nursery one carer is missing during the release. That is an organisational problem, not a reason to skip the order of measures.

Typical mistakes with employment bans

The four most common mistakes in nurseries:

  • No event-independent assessment. It is due under section 10 MuSchG before anyone is pregnant.
  • Blanket ban. Releasing every pregnant employee breaches the order of measures in section 13 MuSchG.
  • Forcing disclosure of immunity. The provider can demand neither disclosure nor vaccination.
  • Report to the wrong body. The state authority is competent, not the BGW or the Unfallkasse.

Anyone who wants to keep the assessment in order needs an occupational safety specialist on site and digital, audit-proof documentation. Safety Club supports office and administrative businesses with predictable annual costs, and the on-site support starts within ten working days. The entry point is the initial consultation, the process is shown on the page How the support works.

This post is general guidance and does not replace legal advice for an individual case. The current versions of the MuSchG and ArbSchG and the interpretation of the supervisory authority responsible for your location are authoritative.

Frequently asked questions

When may a nursery impose an employment ban?

Under section 13 (1) no. 3 MuSchG an employer-imposed employment ban is only permitted if an unacceptable risk cannot be removed by adapting the working conditions or by reassigning the employee. The provider must check both steps beforehand and document the check.

Does a pregnant nursery employee automatically fall under an employment ban?

No. The MuSchG contains no blanket ban. What matters are the assessment under section 10 MuSchG and the woman's immunity status, for example against rubella. Without sufficient immunity, work with contact to children is generally not permitted under section 11 (2) MuSchG.

What is the difference between an employer-imposed and a medical employment ban?

The employer imposes the first under section 13 MuSchG when adapting the work and reassigning are not possible. The second rests on a doctor's certificate under section 16 MuSchG stating that the health of the woman or child is at risk.

Who pays during an employment ban in a nursery?

The provider continues to pay maternity protection pay and, as a rule, gets it reimbursed in full by the health insurer through the U2 levy under the Expenditure Compensation Act. Levy rate and reimbursement are set in the insurer's statutes.

Does the nursery have to demand proof of immunity?

The woman has no duty to disclose it, let alone to be vaccinated. The provider may ask for proof. If none exists, it must assume the less favourable case in the assessment and choose protective measures accordingly.

Does the ban also apply to breastfeeding staff?

Section 12 MuSchG and the same order of measures under section 13 MuSchG apply. The risk is different, so the assessment for the breastfeeding period has to be kept separately.

Does the nursery have to notify the supervisory authority?

Yes. Under section 27 MuSchG the pregnancy must be reported without delay to the competent state authority, not to the accident insurer. The report is due whether or not an employment ban is imposed.

Sources

Newsletter

Don't miss a post

New posts on occupational safety in the office, straight to your inbox.

Not sure what applies to your business?

In a short call we'll tell you what's required and what isn't. Clear, no sales pressure.

Get a consultation

← Back to the blog overview