An in-house workplace safety specialist pays off for an office, arithmetically, only at several thousand employees; an external one is almost always cheaper until then. The reason is the low hours requirement: offices fall into support group III of DGUV Regulation 2 with 0.5 hours of basic support per employee and year, shared between specialist and workplace physician.
If you want to outsource the support, the page on the external workplace safety specialist sets out scope and process: Safety Club offers office businesses predictable annual costs for this. This article shows the calculation behind it and the exceptions, without euro amounts, because those depend on the offer.
What separates the in-house from the external specialist?
The workplace safety specialist (Fachkraft für Arbeitssicherheit) is the person appointed in writing under section 5 of the Workplace Safety Act (ASiG) to advise the employer on workplace safety & health and accident prevention. The person can be employed or come from outside. The duties are the same either way; organisation, cost and utilisation differ.
The ASiG recognises three routes. First, the employed specialist, an employee with expertise under section 7 ASiG. Second, the freelance specialist, commissioned under section 5 ASiG and paid by the hour. Third, the external service provider under section 19 ASiG, which provides several specialists and supplies cover and documentation. How these models differ in detail is covered in 5 support models compared; the formalities of the written appointment in Appointing a workplace safety specialist.
In-house vs. external is therefore less a question of quality than of utilisation. An employed specialist costs the same whether a month is busy or quiet. An external specialist costs only the agreed visits.
How many hours does an office really need?
An office needs 0.5 hours of basic support per employee and year for specialist and workplace physician together, under annex 2 of DGUV Regulation 2 in support group III. At least 20 percent of that must go to each side. Up to 20 employees, annex 1 applies without fixed hours.
The following example assumes a specialist share of 60 percent and a full-time position of 1,600 hours a year. Both are illustrative assumptions, not requirements of the regulation. Business-specific support comes on top and depends on events.
| Employees | Basic support total | of which specialist (60 percent) | Share of a full-time position |
|---|---|---|---|
| 25 | 12.5 hours | 7.5 hours | about 0.5 percent |
| 100 | 50 hours | 30 hours | about 2 percent |
| 250 | 125 hours | 75 hours | about 5 percent |
| 1,000 | 500 hours | 300 hours | about 19 percent |
The table shows why the answer is so clear: an office with 250 employees fills roughly five percent of a specialist position. Even at 1,000 employees, basic support stays below a fifth of a position. The support hours calculator works out the hours for your business including the split between specialist and physician; the derivation is in Calculating support hours under DGUV Regulation 2.
Under these assumptions, a full-time position would be filled by basic support alone only at about 5,300 employees. Business-specific support lowers that threshold, but not into the range where typical mid-sized companies operate.
In-house or external: the comparison in nine criteria
For office businesses, the external specialist wins on cost, cover and effort; the in-house one on proximity and availability. The table sets both side by side. Euro amounts are left out on purpose: they depend on salary or hourly rate and can only be compared with real figures.
| Criterion | Employed specialist | External specialist |
|---|---|---|
| Cost logic | full position, regardless of utilisation | agreed hours or package only |
| Utilisation in an office | below 20 percent of a position up to 1,000 employees | full utilisation at the provider |
| Expertise under section 7 ASiG | company arranges training | provider demonstrates it |
| Further education | cost and time borne by the company | at the provider |
| Cover for leave and illness | company must organise it | provider's duty, set out in contract |
| Co-determination | works council consents under section 9(3) ASiG | same for appointment and dismissal |
| Employer liability | remains under section 3 ArbSchG | remains under section 3 ArbSchG |
| Documentation | in the company, often tied to the person | settle in contract, secure handover |
| Availability | on site every day | by arrangement, visits on site |
Two rows deserve attention. Liability is no basis for the decision: responsibility for workplace safety & health always rests with the employer under section 3 ArbSchG, and outsourcing does not shift it. Documentation is where external arrangements can fail if the contract does not regulate handover of records when changing provider.
What an in-house specialist costs on top
An in-house specialist causes four follow-on costs besides the salary that comparisons often omit: training, further education, cover and equipment. They arise even when the position is only partly used.
- Training: The expertise under section 7 ASiG does not appear by itself. Whoever hands the role to an employee pays for courses and time off before the first hour of support exists.
- Further education: The expertise must stay current. The company bears cost and downtime as long as the person is in the role.
- Cover: If the specialist is absent, support stops. A second qualified person is not worth it for an office, so a gap or an extra contract remains.
- Co-determination and organisation: Where a works council exists, the appointment needs its consent under section 9(3) ASiG. Reporting lines, independence in technical matters and a place in the organisation come on top.
The workplace physician's support is due anyway, in-house or external, because the two roles are separate duties. Workplace physician in the office: duty and scope describes what that looks like.
When an in-house specialist does pay off
An in-house specialist pays off when the business needs clearly more support hours than an office: with many sites, production, warehouse or labs beside administration, with high hazards, or with a headcount in the four-digit range. Then the real demand fills a position, and proximity to the business saves time instead of adding cost.
Typical cases:
- Mixed businesses: administration plus workshop or warehouse has different support groups and hours than a pure office.
- Many sites: inspections and training at several locations add up to hours that can be cheaper in-house.
- Permanently high event-driven demand: conversions, ongoing projects, external contractors, incidents.
- Group structures: several companies can share one specialist if the appointment for each company is set up properly.
For an office with fewer than 250 employees, none of these cases applies in practice. Anyone who sees themselves in one should run the numbers with real figures rather than decide by gut feeling.
Deciding in five steps
The decision follows the hours requirement, not gut feeling. Five steps lead there, each doable with company figures in under an hour.
- Count employees. Part-timers and temporary staff are weighted under section 2 of DGUV Regulation 2; the support group follows from the business's industry code.
- Calculate support hours. Employees times 0.5 hours, of which half to two thirds for the specialist, plus an allowance for business-specific support.
- Convert hours into position shares. Annual need divided by annual working time shows how much of a position would be filled.
- Weigh the extra effort. Training, further education, cover, equipment and the works council's consent belong in the comparison.
- Check offers and contract. For external support, scope, cover, documentation and handover of records count. How to compare offers is shown in What does a safety specialist cost in an office?, what providers charge on the market in the market study.
Anyone who ends up with an external solution after these steps is in good company: in office and administrative businesses it is the normal case.
Safety Club bundles the support for office and administrative businesses in one contract: a workplace safety specialist on site plus digital, audit-proof documentation in the customer portal. Support starts within ten working days after signing, and annual costs are predictable. You will find the process and the initial consultation on the page for the external specialist.
This article is general guidance and does not replace legal advice for your specific case. The current versions of the ASiG and DGUV Regulation 2 and the interpretation of your competent Berufsgenossenschaft apply. The worked examples rest on the stated assumptions and do not replace a quote.




